« DVD Review: Cleaner | Main | Film Review: Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull »

May 21, 2008

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00e54ee7b642883300e55272b0038834

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Film Review: The Fall:

Comments

jenny

You are so off the mark with this one, it's scary, & undermines my opinion of all your reviews. What off camera manipulation? There was no place in which that was obvious, & scenes where Lee Pace is repeating himself- that's the kind of stuff that happens in REAL life when speaking to a child with a language barrier... You think Tarsem couldn't have picked a scene or rehearsed her to get in one take if he wanted? Lee wasn't trying to GET something out of her. I think you've criticized movies too long, you lost your capacity to just EXPERIENCE something. When watching this in a full theatre, the comments about Catinca is that her performance, & the chemistry is stunning. That there is such a purity in the acting- a REALNESS.

Everyone I have taken to see it was moved, touched, AND viually blown away.

(don't quit your day job Brian)

red

The review is right now. The movie was forced and the storyline fell apart about 3/4ths of the way into the movie.

It's an interesting effort but as a movie, it really is DOA.

Great review.

dio

i couldn't agree less about the interaction between Pace and Untaru. to me, that was the ribbon around an extraordinary package, holding it all together.

Aphex

So, I was going to take offense.

Then I saw that you actually enjoyed the shill of the new Indiana flick, and gave Alvin and the Chipmunks a "C" rating.

Seeing that your opinion is actually sub-human in nature, I feel much better - and have little need to prove points.

You know - much like your reviews.

Wow. The Tenacious D movie gets an A? And the CGI-based Superman Returns. Oh, MI:3, too - yeah, that was a totally epic movie.

I guess what I'm trying to say is, "I'm sorry you suck with movies. Get better soon."

Andrew

Aphex is clearly a guy with major insecurities.

And he has no taste in film.

Brian, keep up the great work. THE FALL is an overcooked nightmare unworthy of release.

You're awesome. Aphex is a clown with severe retardation.

Bryan

While one's opinion on if this movie is overindulgent or whatever is really up for grabs, this movie is something visually that rarely comes around. Like him or hate him for doing it, Tarsem has created something of a singularity. Certainly not worthy of a D, if nothing else for the rather genuine and simple relationship between Untaru and Pace.

lyn

Once again a reviewer punishes a film maker for not churning out the asme-old, same-old. Apparently reviewers such as this one only consider a movie worthwhile if they've been told it's good by the talent-killing Hollywood movie machine. This was an excellent movie that satisfied visually and emotionally. Seeing a child who actually acts like a child and not a mini-quip machine, was wonderful. I'll see anything that Tarsem chooses to deliver based on the orginality and vision of his two films.

tomm

'A' for 4th part of Indiana Jones and 'D' for The Fall. That's just ridiculous. You funny:D

Josh

This film is all empty calories. Brian, great review.

Tarsem is repeating himself here, and I laugh at all these comments yelling at you for not proclaiming the picture as the most original creation of the year. It's not.

Only buffoons who see two movies a year would be moved by this lazy piece of garbage.

John S

Never trust a poster who says "Great review ... I agreed with it."

Also, an "overcooked nightmare" is by definition "worthy of release," or at least letting me get a chance to see it. With defenders like that dude, I'm surprised you haven't retracted this piece on principle.

Cam

I you love a good film, not a popcorn movie, something with feeling and love for the simple fact that Tarsem really gave it his all. You can feel the love in this film, the love that went into it. It's not your run of the mill hollywood bullshit! Yeah he used the same style of film making and huge sets and costumes as the Cell, but that is his style. I thank Tarsem for having the balls for making a good FILM not a movie a FILM. The acting is also top notch and real. That you even review movies is a shame. Most of the people here commenting have more of a nack for film than you sir... you should just give it up and keep your face out of reviews.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

My Photo

My Other Accounts

Facebook Twitter